In an industry where test results either don’t exist, and or the test results vary wildly between brands, how in the hell do you made a wise purchase? In this article, we will either help explain our perspective or, make this topic even more confusing. Here goes nothing.
Example; One company says it’s heat exchanger will make your car run 10 degrees cooler (smallest size). Another says 20 (largest), and the 3rd makes no claims at all (average size). Which one would you buy?
In this case, we have invested heavily with “in car” instrumentation, have done the testing and the results are surprising. What we found is that when paired with a 2-gallon fender tank, the difference between the thicker and heavier HX and the lighter CSF unit we use, was zero. That’s because our testing shows that once you upgrade to a larger “full height” HX, add volume and reduce pump restriction, the HX system itself has very little trouble keeping the HX coolant at ambient temperatures. At this level, the issue is getting more heat into the bricks, not shedding heat from the HX.
Clearly… we want to see clear results before making purchases for aftermarket parts like this, but can those results even be duplicated on your car? This is the common dilemma even I find myself in, and as a consumer… the choice is often difficult as you weigh buying from the person or brand you trust, and the product or testing claims you want to be true.
At the end of the day, testing is king, and the results always matter, good and bad. If you’re a designer or manufacturer, testing is where you find out whether it fits, whether it holds up, and whether it does what you designed it to do. How much of the results will be shared, and what results should matter to the person buying the part is a different question.
What did the testing actually answer?
I felt this firsthand during our LT4 camshaft shootout. We spent five days on the engine dyno and made nearly 100 pulls. I remember thinking that if the numbers looked too good, people would wonder what we did to get them. If they looked too low, people would assume we’d screwed something up. Either way, somebody was going to have an opinion.
One of my favorite results was a combination comparison where Cam A made 951 horsepower at 18.9 psi and Cam B that made 1,006 horsepower at 15.8 psi. Those numbers were worth publishing because they showed what those combinations did on the same test engine, but with the dozens of variables that fall within testing parameters, it’s not wise to lean on those to hard. When selecting a camshaft for instance, power band, idle quality, and lobe design matter so much more than peak numbers.
We also made choices about how we loaded the engine and where we softened timing because we wanted repeatable high-RPM pulls and an engine that would survive the week. If you ask me which cam makes the most torque from 2,500 to 4,000 RPM in your streetcar, I can’t settle that with those graphs.
Bias can creep in before the first pull. You can choose a favorable baseline, start one run with cooler fluid, or pick the one run that makes the biggest difference look typical. A “best-case” test can be useful when you explain what makes it best-case. And when a company keeps its testing internal, you could be looking at anything from a lot of development work to very little. This is where we seem to be put right in the middle of the fork in the road. Purchase from the brand / person you trust, or the claims we want to believe.
Why are you upgrading in the first place?
Sometimes I just want a part because it looks cool. I’m fine saying that. If I’m buying a supercharger lid because I like the look and want more blower whine, I don’t need to settle whether it makes seven horsepower or seventeen. If horsepower is what makes the price worth it to you, then then you need to take that leap of faith, and assume that the testing was fair, reliable and true.
Some parts make more sense when you look at what changed in the design. Take a stamped rear control arm and a boxed steel arm. On the bench, you can measure how much each flex under the same load. On the car, how much wheel hop did that one arm take out? Now you’ve got bushings, other links, tires, alignment and the surface in the picture. Change several pieces and get the alignment right and the rear end may feel more planted. That tells you something about the whole setup. It’s hard to hand one arm all the credit.
What intercooler bricks taught me about selling a result
The LT4 charge-air cooling loop has two jobs. The bricks transfer heat from the compressed intake air into the coolant. The front heat exchangers transfer that heat from the coolant to outside air. Installed coolant flow depends on the pump and the pressure drop through the entire loop. Extra coolant volume adds thermal mass, which helps slow the temperature rise during a pull. The heat still has to leave through the front exchangers.
That’s why I’m skeptical when someone sells one part as the fix for the whole system. If you already have enough flow and enough heat rejection up front, the bricks might be the next place to work. Put those same bricks into a car whose coolant gets hotter with each pull and barely recovers, and you may still have the problem you started with.
I’ve done dyno and street testing on the new CSF 1.7L Intercooler bricks, and customers have done testing of their own. I’ve kept most of those results private and here’s why. On a hot day with long, back-to-back pulls, a few degrees of charge-air temperature could be enough to keep the ECU out of an area where the calibration pulls ignition timing. If that happens, the car can hang on to more of its power on the later pulls. On another car, with a different calibration or different starting temperatures, the same change in temperature might never affect timing at all. On our recent DYNO test, we saw a 20hp gain with the CSF bricks, based on lower IAT’s pull after pull. Are we going to lead with that tag line? No, and not because it’s not relevant, but because your results will vary.
When I look at the bricks as an upgrade, I want to know how the core is built, how much coolant volume it adds, and how it flows under comparable conditions. Those are things I can evaluate about the part itself. Then I can ask whether my cooling system is set up to take advantage of it.
In our case, we are removing an older tube and fin design with thin mounting brackets, in exchange for a much more durable bar and plate design, 70% more coolant, 50% taller, with better coolant flow. It’s those core design changes that we can guarantee, although we hope you see the same 20hp gain or more, it’s clear that leading with that is not our style.
So, what are you actually buying then?
In some cases, you are buying “the brand” and the assumption of testing.
BTR is a great example. Everyone knows they invest heavily in spintron testing, DYNO testing, durability testing… yet as a consumer, when your reading about the Stage.1 PD blower cam, you don’t see wild HP claims, no “we are the best” just a simple product description.
In this case, you’re investing in the brand, and general understanding of testing and quality. Do their cams make the most power? That depends on the application. Are they the durable, and do they play will with matching BTR parts? Absolutely.
So, Gabe… WTF should we take away from this?
1. Testing sucks… but it’s a critical step that everyone does in one way or another, but not everyone shares… and that’s not always a bad thing.
2. Brands & People Matter. At the end of the day, you are investing in a person and company, and or the companies they trust. If and when sh*t hits the fan you want the person you’re trying to call to answer the damn phone.
3. Be wary of claims that appear to be “too good to be true”. Some companies know that buyers will purchase on claims alone, and will exploit that with hero numbers that may not even be achievable.
4. When in doubt, pick up the phone. If you can’t get them on the phone to tell you the story, then you may want to think twice about making the order. In my experience a company or person that is too busy to discuss their product on the phone before you purchase, is never the company that want to talk when things go sideways.
At Griffin Motorsports, we take testing, R&D, fitment and finish seriously. I take great pride in the products we make, test, resell and use on my personal vehicle. You can call me anytime and I’d be happy to tell you what works well, and what doesn’t work at all. At the end of the day, I care much more about the relationship I have with my customer, vendors and dealers.
Whether you buy from me or someone else, I want you to end up with the right combination of parts for your car. If you call me, I’ll tell you what we tested, what worked, and where I’d want to know more about your setup before I told you to spend money in our efforts to Go Faster & Stay Cooler.